Shopping Cart
Your Cart is Empty
Quantity:
Subtotal
Taxes
Shipping
Total
There was an error with PayPalClick here to try again
CelebrateThank you for your business!You should be receiving an order confirmation from Paypal shortly.Exit Shopping Cart

PAPRA

Pennsylvania Property Rights Association

Blog

Blog

Setting the Stage for a New School Property Tax Elimination Bill!

Posted by Jim Rodkey on January 30, 2019 at 4:30 PM

Note: This is the first part of a series of articles intnended to introduce HB13.  We will explore why we feel this new step is important to the process and the advantages of working through this new concept in School Property Tax Elimination.


As we move closer to seeing HB13 move from being proposed legislation to becoming an actual bill, we felt it was time to bring others up to speed on what is happening. Before we do so, we thought it would be beneficial to discuss one particular aspect concerning School Property Tax Elimination.

If any legislation regarding School Property Tax Elimination is to pass, the “Political Will” to do so has to be generated. The fact of the matter is that, while we all know that the school property tax system has problems, the degree of those problems is not generally recognized across the state.

In our opinion, and in our experiences through the countless town halls in which we have participated, the problem is generally recognized among the people but, legislatively, the problem is often diminished or, in the most extreme cases, dismissed. We’ve had more than our share of legislators who tell us it is not a problem in their district and yet, in town hall after town hall, we find the exact opposite to be true when we speak directly with the constituents in that district.

Furthermore, the amendment advanced by the legislative body clearly demonstrates that the problem is recognized by a very large percentage of the people across the state. Overwhelmingly, the state voted to move to some alternative to funding education other than the property tax. While this should have sent a clear message to our legislators, the political system has this awkward habit of spinning everything while looking for political expediency rather than doing the right thing because it’s the right thing to do. That may not be as much of a political issue as it is a part of human nature. We tend to seek the path of least resistance; to look for the easiest path and, at present, disregarding the long-term impact of School Property Taxation is the easiest path. However, if we continue down this unsustainable path, failing to recognize those long-term effects, we will reach point where something will have to be done and by that time, no matter what is done, the damage created by ignoring those long-term issues, will be very difficult to overcome.

The cold hard fact is that it isn’t going to be enough just to force a vote on any school property tax elimination bill. As it stands right now, any proposed legislation will fail because the political will to do the right thing simply isn’t there. That may frustrate you. It may even make you angry. Frustration and anger, however, is not enough.

Looking for the path of least resistance is not our only problem. We also have to concern ourselves with something identified as the “normalcy bias”. This is the belief that causes people to underestimate both the likelihood of a disaster and its possible effects, because people believe that things will always function the way things normally have functioned. It’s sort of an inherent safety valve that prevents many people from understanding the devasting long-term impact of following an unsustainable course of action.

It is not a problem unique to politicians. It is a problem with the larger society as a whole.

As bad as things are with the property tax at this point in time, the inescapable long-term conclusion, confirmed though the Independent Fiscal Office by studying historical increases in property taxation is that the school property tax burden will double in about 18 years. If wages do not match that increase coupled to keeping the cost of living in alignment to the increased property tax burden, we have a recipe for disaster concerning home-ownership. The historical record demonstrates that wages will not match the increased demand through property taxation and that cost-of-living, as a result of this we will see less money to provide for the revenue demanded through property taxation. In other words, in 18 years, we reach that point of absolute unsustainability. At that point in time, the replacement revenue for school property taxes will have doubled.

Let’s make this clear: if Pennsylvania wants to increase the percentage of out-migrating young working families while generating more government dependency programs, than it should stay on the path it is on. We should all understand the consequences of following that path. Less working age families means less state PIT and SUT income to fund these government programs and that places a higher funding burden on those still living in the Commonwealth.

The third aspect in play is that, while the majority may want to see property taxes eliminated, we cling to this notion that shifting to a different system for replacement revenue should include everybody but our specific group. Many may be perfectly fine with carving out exemptions for specific groups, as we’ve done with Keystone Opportunity Zones (KOZs), Local Economic Revitalization Tax Assistance (LERTAs), Clean and Green and other programs that provide property tax relief by passing that burden on to other working families but, again, we have to consider the long-term implications of doing so. We hear the same narratives when it comes to creating Senior exemptions.

The revenue for education funding has to be generated and every exemption, regardless of how necessary it may seem on the surface, only spreads that revenue demand to fewer people creating greater burdens for that dwindling tax base. This is a band-aid approach to a much larger problem that, rather than solving problems, generally results in creating a whole set of new problems.

When it comes to funding education, the future of our children should be everyone’s responsibility. We may all agree in the importance of a sound education, where we disagree is who should pay for it.

Right now, the lion’s share of that funding comes from our family homes. Since this system is not based on ability to pay, it creates some very serious implications. We also know, regardless of how it is framed, the school property tax system is a system that is rife with inequality issues generating a very regressive education funding system that already dramatically impacts the younger working families in this Commonwealth.

We can continue to ignore that or we can face the harsh reality that property taxation is one of the reasons we see dwindling rates of home-ownership, increases in rent, out-migration of young working families, while contributing to the problems of blight and abandoned properties. Government programs created to “help” in these instances may sound good on the surface, but all government programs require government funding and that increases the tax burden on the very working families that these programs as claimed as help by the government. Those government programs require the establishment of more bureaucracies to maintain them and all of that comes at a cost to the tax payer. In many cases, the long-term cost outweighs any benefits we may see in the short-term.

Over the past year, PAPRA, in working with Frank Ryan, State representative for the 101st district in Pennsylvania, has spent countless hours discussing each of the aspects in attempting to create a strategic narrative in advancing School Property Tax Elimination. We know that, in order to generate the political will to do this, all of these points must become a part of internal narrative within the political body. These points must be driven home to generate the political will to bring about the total elimination of the School Property Tax, paving the way for alternative means for the future complete elimination of all Property Taxation.

At the same time, Frank Ryan has been meeting with other legislators which has opened doors of communication previously unexplored in the property tax debate. These new areas have created more input and discussions that potentially make a very good proposal even better. Having other legislative input is healthy because it brings in unique perspectives that are common in one County or district that is uncommon in other areas. It allows us to address each of these issues and look for the best overall solution for the entire state.

Having other voices in this process has proven to be healthy and a much needed part of generating the political will necessary for School Property Tax Elimination to happen. At the same, these discussion lead to more legislative conversations that all draw attention to the many problems associated with Property Taxation. The more that these problems are openly discussed, the greater the chances we have in drawing attention to the long-term negative impact of staying on the current path.

The goal here is school property tax elimination. To do that we need to generate the replacement revenue and that revenue should be provided in a way that is as equitable as possible while maintaining the Constitution requirements of tax uniformity preventing future substantive court challenges. I believe that we are steadfastly on the path and have created a much stronger support network in the process.

As I stated, the goal here is elimination and, like it or not, to get to that goal we need 102, 26 and 1: the votes necessary from the house, senate and governor for approval. For a proposal making its way to becoming a bill, we’re on a solid path to building a strong legislative coalition and, and least to me, that’s good news.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Categories: None

Post a Comment

Oops!

Oops, you forgot something.

Oops!

The words you entered did not match the given text. Please try again.

Already a member? Sign In

2717 Comments

Reply Rishmxj
9:32 AM on February 23, 2022 
50 best managed it small businesses

VPBank named in Top 50 Best learning Companies

Pham Phu Khoi, VPBank's Deputy General movie director, gets hold of the award. Photo courtesy of the bank VPBank has been honoured in the "Viet Nam's 50 Best making time for Companies" (TOP50) For five consecutive years thanks to its proactive business focus and taking care of risks well during the pandemic in Viet Nam. The bank always has many active methods to support customers to overcome conflicts and continuously gain success. VPBank was also one of 20 businesses in the TOP50's billion US dollar how to tell if a chinese girl likes you club despite fierce contest in the financial banking market as well as negative impacts from the pandemic. This is an annual ranking developed by Nhip cau dau tu Magazine in tandem with Thien Viet Securities to honour the very best companies on Viet Nam's stock exchange. To objectively assess the management capacity of enterprises, TOP50 evaluates businesses' results of three consecutive fiscal years, Based on three signs: taking, come on equity (ROE) And cash flow per share more.] About VPBank named in Top 50 Best appearing CompaniesVit Nam refutes 'false' claim on militia deployment in East SeaLk Lake, A relaxing spot in the Central Highlands16,715 new COVID 19 cases reported on ThursdayMasan Group Top ASEAN consumer pick to be able to Bank of America16,715 new cases launched on January 20Vit Nam, Hungary foster parliamentary cooperationApple discontinues full-sized HomePod, to pay attention to HomePod miniiPhone demand weakness just 'noise,' outlook is strong, Analyst saysAd helped HBO Max option coming in JuneApple Watch SE returns to $259, Cellular $309 in today's Amazon dealsDaVinci Resolve and Fusion now basically support M1 Macs.
Reply DJGiankoExirm
4:48 AM on February 24, 2022 
Hello,

FTP service is a community for DJ’s & fans that helps you gain full access to exclusive electronic music various artists, singles trax. http://0daymusic.org
https://0daymusic.org/premium.php

Best Regards, DJ Gianko
Reply Rickqoi
3:49 PM on February 24, 2022 
Day Saint billionaire basically faith

salt LAKE CITY (AP) an advertising technology billionaire has formally resigned his membership in The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter day Saints and rebuked the faith over social issues and LGBTQ rights in an unusual public move.

rob T. Green has pledged to give 90% of his estimated $5 billion fortune, you start with a $600,000 donation to the LGBTQ rights group equality Utah, The Salt Lake Tribune published.

Green said in a Monday resignation letter to church president charmingdate Russell M. Nelson that he hasn't been active in the faith for over a decade but wanted to make his departure official and remove his name from membership records.

"in my opinion the Mormon church has hindered global progress in women's rights, Civil rights and racial equal rights, And LGBTQ+ the law, He submitted. Eleven members of the family and a friend formally resigned along with him.

The church didn rapidly return a message from The Associated Press seeking comment Tuesday, But realize it's a huge has shown a willingness to engage on LGBTQ rights that is unusual for a conservative faith. It maintains its doctrinal amount of resistance to same sex marriage and intimacy, But the faith didn block a 2019 ban on so called conversion therapy in Utah and in November high ranking leader Dallin Oaks called for a status of both religious rights and LGBTQ rights.

in spite of everything, The church has taken positions over the years which has been deeply painful for many in the LGBTQ community. yellow, For his point, Said most church patrons "Are good people wanting to do right, But he also worries about the faith's transparency around its history and finances.

organic, 44, Now lives in southern california. He is the CEO and chairman on Trade Desk, a marketing technology firm he founded in 2009.

He also mentioned concerns about a $100 billion real estate investment portfolio held by the faith. It was the subject of an internal revenue service whistleblower complaint in 2019, From a former employee who charged the church had improperly built it up using member donations that are supposed to go to charitable causes.

Leaders have defended how the church uses and invests member shawls by hoda donates, Saying most is used for operational and humanitarian needs, But a portion is safeguarded to build a reserve for future years. The faith annually spends about $1 billion on non profit and welfare aid, leaders have said.

The church has also come under criticism for lower social positions. Women do not hold the priesthood in the faith, And Black men could not prior to 1970s.

these days, however, The faith has caused the NAACP and donated nearly $10 million for initiatives to help Black Americans. It has also caused Equality Utah to pass a state LGBTQ nondiscrimination law, With religious exemptions.

Another notable onetime Latter day Saint sued the faith this year, Accusing it of fraud and seeking to recover sums of money in contributions. James Huntsman is a member of one of Utah's most well known families and brother of a former governor. The suit was later thrown out.
Reply tadalafil cialis
7:50 PM on February 24, 2022 
cialis cost tadalafil cialis
Reply cialis 20 mg
10:12 PM on February 24, 2022 
cialis tadalafil tadalafil blood pressure
Reply cialis online
1:07 PM on February 25, 2022 
where to buy cialis without prescription cialis cost
Reply buy cialis usa
1:29 AM on February 26, 2022 
tadalafil generic where to buy buy tadalafil
Reply tadalafil generic where to buy
2:06 AM on February 26, 2022 
generic cialis tadalafil tadalafil blood pressure
Reply oridoqxcn
3:19 PM on February 27, 2022 
prescription tadalafil online tadalafil price walmart
Reply Coffcromb
10:07 PM on February 27, 2022 
https://oscialipop.com - Cialis Medicament Lioresal Rykfte cialis online without Purchasing Isotretinoin https://oscialipop.com - cialis 20mg price cialis contre levitra Kznctr
Reply side effects for tadalafil
4:06 PM on February 28, 2022 
buy tadalafil tadalafil drug
Reply cialis pills
4:29 PM on February 28, 2022 
tadalafil liquid buy tadalis
Reply generic cialis
9:51 AM on March 3, 2022 
https://nextadalafil.com/ tadalafil cost in canada
Reply canada generic tadalafil
2:24 PM on March 3, 2022 
cialis without a prescription tadalafil goodrx
Reply SguUBrNoZJqmE
9:01 PM on March 4, 2022 
ONYKsRhHjXTSW
Reply cheapest tadalafil cost
9:36 PM on March 4, 2022 
where to get tadalafil where to order tadalafil tablets
Reply cialis 20 mg
3:05 PM on March 5, 2022 
buy cialis pills tadalafil dosage
Reply oridoyerp
5:43 PM on March 6, 2022 
tadalafil daily online https://cialisvet.com/
Reply tadalafil cialis
3:15 PM on March 7, 2022 
buy tadalafil where to get tadalafil
Reply cheap cialis
7:37 PM on March 8, 2022 
prescription tadalafil online cost of cialis